Picking Retail Stocks In The Amazon Era
In the relatively short life of YCharts, we have written more than three dozen articles on Amazon (AMZN) – not because we’re fans of the stock but because it poses a unique problem for value investors:
Amazon’s stock trades at such a crazy valuation that owning it requires a leap of faith many value investors aren’t willing to make. At the same time, Amazon’s brutal competitive behavior has transformed retailing, and buying any other retail stock without first gauging its vulnerability to Amazon would be a foolish move.
Shorting Amazon, of course, would probably be nuttier than buying it, as investors enamored of its disruptive (ands destructive) business model have piled into the stock, even as the company’s operations have failed to produce regular profits. For this reason we’ve nicknamed Amazon the Suicide Bomber of Retail, a company that ruins the business of competitors while also trashing its own bottom line.
One of our favorite investment writers, Jack Hough of Barron’s, tackled this same topic over the weekend. He noted: “a company that can win cheers on Wall Street while shunning profits is a dangerous foe.” Hough, as we do, finds Amazon shares pricey and also worries that other retailer stocks are at risk because of the online merchant’s aggressive pricing and (to be fair) its fabulous service.
Indeed, this chart of soaring revenue, and a narrowing profit margin gone negative, suggests a company that is selling dollar bills for 99 cents apiece, and hoping to make it on volume. If you’re a competing retailer – say Best Buy (BBY) or Barnes & Noble (BKS) – and investors do value you on profitability, it must seem horribly unfair, and impossible to succeed.
Even when its losing money, Amazon has fabulous cash flow; it gets paid almost immediately when you use your Visa (V) or MasterCard (MA) to buy stuff on the site, and its deals with suppliers allow it to pay them later. Each sale of goods is therefore cash-positive. That has allowed Amazon to be a price cutter and to invest enormous sums in new warehouses and new Amazon employees to support its sales growth.
So, investors really must weigh a retailer stock’s vulnerability to Amazon. Mark Miller, an analyst at William Blair in Chicago, regularly assesses such vulnerability by measuring product overlap retailers have with Amazon; comparing prices on those overlapping items; and gauging the shopping experience of other retailers to see if there is some fun, comfort, convenience or other factors that would thwart Amazon.
All but Cabela’s – see our article on its reliance on gun sales – have outperformed the S&P 500 since our article, but they haven’t matched the surge in Amazon shares.
One could easily jump on the Amazon bandwagon. Isn’t a company so dominant and disruptive inherently a good investment? Affluent enough to invest in stocks, chances are you’ve also been buying lots of stuff on Amazon and perhaps enjoying the free shipping from Amazon Prime, which sent the company’s shipping costs soaring but also gave it a much-needed extension of revenue growth.
Hough, the Barron’s writer, notes, however that Amazon’s disclosure of its costs in various of its businesses is so scant that one can’t really build a reliable model for how the company becomes wonderfully profitable. And yet, analysts following Amazon see EPS of $10.61 in 2016. That will require yet more revenue growth, and that’s hard to come by without aggressive price-cutting, which, of course, trashes margins. Short of believing all the other retailers go out of business, we’re back to that leap of faith, one that’s difficult for value investors to make.
Jeff Bailey, The Editor of YCharts, is a former reporter, editor and columnist at the Wall Street Journal and New York Times. He can be reached at email@example.com. Read the RIABiz profile of YCharts. You can also request a demonstration of YCharts Platinum.
- stocks that look cheap
- pharma stocks
- tech stocks
- stocks that look pricey
- money managers
- value investing
- retail stocks
- dividend growth
- income investing
- energy stocks
- stock buybacks
- growth stocks
- earnings season
- warren buffett
- bank stocks
- stock screener
- short sellers
- dividend yields
- dividend yield
- interest rates
- healthcare stocks
- junk bonds
- executive compensation
- fast food stocks