Dividend Seekers: Utility Stocks are Pricey Now – Here’s the Path to Shares With Dividend Growth
Everything you need to know about investor sentiment right now can be found in the utility sector. This staid corner of the market has always been the go-to sector for yield seekers. Now more than ever: The likes of Consolidated Edison (ED), Southern Co. (SO), PG&E (PCG) and Dominion Resources (D) all serve up dividend yields that are more than double the 1.5% yield for a 10-year Treasury note.
What yield seekers might not realize though is that legions of risk averse investors spooked by market volatility and starved for yield have bid up utility stocks to pricey levels.
Historically, the utility sector has an average price/earnings ratio about 25% below the overall market. Today the sector trades at a large premium to the market. According to S&P IQ, the utility sector within the S&P 500 stock index has a PE ratio of 15.6 based on estimated 2012 earnings. The overall PE ratio for the S&P 500 index is 13.1. And with a forecast of sluggish earnings growth in 2013 for the sector, that high valuation is expected to persist next year as well. S&P IQ forecasts a 15.1 2013 PE ratio for the utility sector, compared to 11.7 for the overall S&P 500.
That seems like a pretty steep price to be paying for yield. Sure, as long as investor sentiment remains wary-to-scared, this “defensive” sector will remain in demand. But those high valuations could spell trouble once sentiment shifts.
Another factor that needs vetting when fishing for yield in utilities is the dividend payout ratio. The utility sector has always had a much higher payout ratio than the broad market; that’s just a function of it being a lower-growth industry that churns out steady dividends. The average payout ratio over the past 10 years has been around 60% according to FactSet, compared to less than 30% for the S&P 500.
That said, before you chase after a high yield, it pays to check the dividend payout ratio.
Compare that to PPL Corp (PPL).
If you’re looking for a Treasury beating yield, selling at a below average price-earnings ratio and a payout ratio that gives the company room to grow the dividend (hopefully at an inflation-beating pace) you might want to expand beyond the utility sector.
You can use the YCharts Stock Screener to find your own high-paying stocks, and then analyze each issue further with YCharts’ other metrics by clicking on the stock symbols in this article.
Take a look at Chevron (CVX). A 3% yield from a company that has consistently increased its dividend, yet still has a low payout ratio. Meanwhile, the current PE ratio is about half the average PE ratio for the utility sector.
Not grooving on energy? Okay, how about a techie. Here’s Applied Materials (AMAT).
Or a stable insurer per chance? Here’s AFLAC (AFL).
You get the idea. There are ways to get yield today from companies with steady earnings, without having to pay up for a pricey utility.
Filed under: Investing Ideas