Bad Coffee Nation: Dunkin Brands vs. Starbucks

The week before Christmas was a crummy one for those holding Dunkin Brands (DNKN) shares, as the donut-and-coffee franchise king reduced its guidance on results for the fourth quarter of 2014 and for all of 2015 -- same-store sales increases coming in lower than previously forecast being the most notable metric.

DNKN Chart

DNKN data by YCharts

Dunkin’s CEO Nigel Travis -- “Nigel” seems an upper crust name for a donut boss, but the man has down-market cred; he previously worked at Papa John’s (PZZA), Blockbuster and Burger King (BKW) -- promised, beyond 2015, “we are committed to returning to double-digit growth.” The company continues to add hundreds of stores.

Those seeing last week’s stock dive as a buying opportunity, however, might think twice. Once because Dunkin shares remain dear, trading at a forward PE ratio of nearly 25. That reflects our ebullient market, with major indexes hitting records in recent days, and the general mania for coffee-driven investments. Twice because wringing sustained increases in same-store sales from coffee-and-pastry joints, going forward, is going to require some fancy footwork. Dunkin mightn’t be the one to pull it off.

Continue Reading

Morningstar’s New Wide-Moat Stock List Bargains

If you’re sniffing around looking for values in the energy sector, the just-reconstituted Market Vectors Wide Moat ETF (MOAT) that tracks the Morningstar Wide Moat index needs to be on your must-vet list. For the upcoming first quarter of 2015, eight of the 20 spots in the equal-weighted portfolio will be energy stocks that have the double allure of possessing a competitive wide moat and a share price that Morningstar estimates is a discount to fair value.

The three steepest discounts are Schlumberger (SLB), National Oilwell Varco (NOV) and Williams Companies (WMB) all selling at discounts of at least 25%. Those discounts are based on a fresh round of reduced fair value estimates from Morningstar that reflect the sell-off in oil prices.

A quick aside if you’re not familiar with the success of the wide moat index: Morningstar’s index has a terrific long-term record, and the Market Vectors ETF that was launched in mid 2012 to track it has in its short history has managed to more than keep pace with the SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY). (Full disclosure: Morningstar is an investor in YCharts.)

MOAT Total Return Price Chart

MOAT Total Return Price data by YCharts

A testament to the stock-picking chops for the Wide Moat ETF is that outperformance comes despite having a 49 basis point expense ratio drag, compared to just 9 basis points for the SPDR S&P 500 ETF.

Continue Reading

The Failure of Non-Traditional Bonds in 2014

Old school high-quality bonds were supposed to be the dogs of 2014. The popular meme among the bond cognoscenti heading into this year was that given the end of the 30+ year cyclical bull market for bonds, you had to get creative and venture far beyond the traditional bond fodder -- Treasuries, government backed bonds, high quality corporates -- to position yourself for the new world order. The explicit message: how or why would you be content sticking with a traditional bond fund or ETF tracking the Barclays U.S. Aggregate index with its piddly 2% yield?

And let’s remember that it was also just a year ago that municipal bonds were still nursing wounds from a year full of headline -- if not fundamental -- risk.

As this chart shows, staying old school in fact paid off quite well in 2014. The iShares Core Total U.S. Bond Market ETF (AGG) that tracks the all-U.S., all high grade Barclays US Aggregate index and the iShares S&P National AMT-Free ETF (MUB) posted strong total returns, while the high yielding non-traditional fare struggled to stay afloat:

AGG Total Return Price Chart

AGG Total Return Price data by YCharts

Now to be clear, both the junk and senior loan ETFs bested the higher quality fare over the past five years:

Continue Reading

Safe 4% Yield Positioned for Energy Rebound

Chevron (CVX) has badly lagged the broad SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY) this year, which should come as absolutely no surprise given the cratering in oil prices.

CVX Chart

CVX data by YCharts

But over the past three weeks an interesting divergence has emerged. Chevron stock is no longer tracking the sharp decline in oil. Here’s a zoom into performance from December 1:

Continue Reading

Church of Starbucks: Ahead, Belief Required

With a few ups-and-downs, Starbucks (SBUX) shares essentially marked time in 2014, up just 3% as we write this, after a spectacular 2013 performance that featured a 43% rise in the coffee seller’s stock.

View 2014 as a year of consolidating gains, then, but Starbucks enters 2015 (the fiscal year actually ended September 28) with an audacious growth program that could make current trading levels a nice entry point. Or, if there is failure to execute on an increasingly complex business model, the 2014 pause could be viewed in hindsight as what was an excellent and sustained opportunity to hop off CEO Howard Schultz’s happiness bus.

SBUX Chart

SBUX data by YCharts

Schultz’s twin attributes – grandiose self-regard and weakness for the worst of business clichés, coupled with an amazing rigor and discipline in operating the hot-drinks chain – attach a cult of personality to Starbucks shares, and perhaps a Howard-premium to go with it; the PE ratio based on trailing net income is just shy of 30 right now.

For the love of clichés, sample this buzzword-heavy quote attributed to Chairman Howard (God help his family and friends if the guy actually talks like this; we’ve helpfully italicized the most obvious clichés jammed into his remarks) in Starbucks’ recent announcement of the new five-year plan:

Continue Reading

Holding Stocks Hoping To Get Back To . . . ?

Financial advisors often call it a case of “get-back-itis,” the urge many investors have to hold onto losing stock positions until the shares return to some arbitrary level, like the buyer’s purchase price or, in extreme examples, the stock’s high.

S Chart

S data by YCharts

If you happened to buy some of 2014’s big losers – here we see year-to-date results for Sprint (S), Twitter (TWTR), Mattel (MAT), Las Vegas Sands (LVS) and Amazon (AMZN) – you, too, may be feeling the urge to hang on in hopes that your losses are covered by a subsequent gain in the stock. Don’t, unless your up-to-the-minute analysis of the stock suggests you’d buy it now at its current price.

Get-back-itis is also known as the Anchor Trap, and is among a handful of behavioral financial biases explained in a YCharts White Paper; click on the link to download the full report. Most investor suffer from some irrational beliefs that hamper their performance. The white paper explains these biases and offers ways to avoid suffering losses due to them.

Continue Reading

Cheaper Plays On Consumer Spending Surge

Falling oil prices, rising consumer confidence amid an improving labor market, and a smidge of wage increases is not surprisingly fueling expectations for consumer discretionary stocks to outperform. Since the mid October low, the Vanguard Consumer Discretionary ETF (VCR) and the Consumer Discretionary Select SPDR (XLY) are significantly outpacing the broad market SPSR S&P 500 (SPY).

VCR Total Return Price Chart

VCR Total Return Price data by YCharts

Benefitting from a pickup in consumer spending -- regardless of what is purchased -- are the intermediary payment systems. Both Visa (V) and MasterCard (MA) have indeed been bid up since sentiment shifted in mid October.

Continue Reading

In Department Store Stocks, One Isn’t Full-Priced

It’s not news that consumer discretionary stocks are topping the lists of projected 2015 outperformers. Piper Jaffrey pegs the sector as one of its three overweight ideas (along with healthcare and technology) in the year ahead. And Piper Jaffrey is still decidedly bullish on 2015. It’s 2,350 estimate for the S&P 500 is about 15% higher than where it recently traded.

Exchange traded funds such as Vanguard Consumer Discretionary (VCR) offer a cheap and broad way to tilt toward this sector. The three largest positions, Walt Disney (DIS), Home Depot (HD) and Amazon (AMZN) speak to the broad range of consumer stocks.

For a more nuanced look with consumer discretionary, the Leuthold Group recently called out Retail Home Furnishings and Department Stores as having moved up into their “Attractive” group rating.

In fact, U.S. home furnishing store sales are up more than 4% year to date, and that’s half of the entire sales growth this slice of the economy registered in the preceding five years:

US Furniture and Home Furnishings Store Sales Chart

US Furniture and Home Furnishings Store Sales data by YCharts

Department stores haven’t had the same bounce. Store sales are down nearly 2% over the past year. But in a market where it’s hard to find value, department stores are intriguing: they are an unloved and beaten up sector that has reasonable upside in an environment where consumers have more to spend away from the suddenly less-expensive gas pump. Moreover, while real wage growth was anemic into 2013, it has begun to pick up:

Continue Reading

McDonald’s: Biggest Problem Isn’t Self-Inflicted

I’ve asked a number of times over the years – of Leggett & Platt (LEG) in the furniture industry, and of Southwest Airlines (LUV) in air travel, for instance – is it possible to be a great company in a crummy industry?

Meaning, no matter how well managed and financially sound a company is, will the overall poor economics in its industry overwhelm it? For Leggett & Platt, which makes furniture components, a poorly-capitalized and innovation-challenged group of furniture makers and retailers has held back its performance for years. And for Southwest, despite a soaring stock this year, the company has suffered in recent years because of its rivals’ failures; bankruptcies allowed United (UAL) Delta (DAL) and American (AAL) to shed expensive plane leases, union contracts and pension obligations, putting the better-managed Southwest at a competitive disadvantage.

MCD Revenue (TTM) Chart

MCD Revenue (TTM) data by YCharts

McDonald’s (MCD) may be in a similar situation. That, of course, is not what one mostly reads about the company these days. We’re told its CEO, Don Thompson, can’t seem to get the growth recipe right; that the menu’s too sprawling; that McDonald’s needs to let customers build their own burgers; and that more innovation needs to bubble up from franchisees.

Continue Reading

Index-Crushing Fund Buys Fastenal During Sell-Off

The Sequoia mutual fund (M:SEQUX) is an actively managed portfolio well worth parsing. Over the past 20 years it has obliterated the S&P 500.

SEQUX Total Return Price Chart

SEQUX Total Return Price data by YCharts

How Sequoia generates those returns is especially interesting: it does pretty well in up markets but its huge value added comes from not losing as much in down markets. Morningstar reports that Sequoia has captured about 77% of the market’s upside moves over the past 15 years while managing to suffer just 49% of the downside. Not a bad approach to have at this juncture in a very long bull market.

If Sequoia has flown under your radar, that’s because it has spent much of the past few decades either entirely or partially closed to new investors as management has carefully avoided fund bloat. Assets are a relatively puny $8 billion for one of the rare consistent index beaters.

Continue Reading

< Newer Articles | Older Articles >

Search Articles

Subscribe to YCharts Analysis

Editorial Team

  • CEO & Publisher Shawn Carpenter
  • Editor Jeff Bailey
  • Contributing Editors Dee Gill, Carla Fried, Emily Lambert, Bill Barnhart, Kathy Kristof, Stephane Fitch, Larry Barrett, Bill Bulkeley, Mark Henricks, Suzanne McGee, Ed Silverman, David J. Phillips, Katherine Reynolds Lewis, Theo Francis, Condrad de Aenlle, Amy Merrick
Read about our team


Start your free 14 Day Trial.

{{}} No credit card required.

Already a subscriber? Sign in.